the possum witch kept offering the position, but every time lil miss refused. she only accepted as a desperate plea because they realized whisper was at the church (only that he was there, not that his life was threatened or anything. they found out recently he’d been going back and forth just fine.) so it was a rushed “hes in danger! OMG!” without fully knowing that.

so, I’d say it was there, but really not enforced in a good way. lil miss never wanted it, forced to accept (because may as well to save whisper and her eye was already yoinked as a desperate bit to save ash- who got her whole back end crushed by a car on the way- that whisper mercy killed anyway. leaving lil miss sacrifice useless, but then reused to become witch and save whisper), then plays happily ever after with new powers.

From what I’m seeing, a lot of people liked IDK until Whisper started doing his thing, then Little Miss became a witch. Does that feel like it came out of nowhere, or was such a thing established, but the execution wasn’t good?

I still don’t get the killing of disabled animals. What was the point of that?

Feels like I’m not missing much by not reading IDK.

I think the character reveal fits because it does set up the sequel, but like you said you can stop reading there and be satisfied with the story. At the very least She gets her comeuppance. The criticism was fair though. I’m also glad the author didn’t mind because it is a refreshing change from other authors who act like you’ve ruined their lives. Agree to disagree just doesn’t exist. I don’t think SD or Sleepy are as bad as Kique by a long shot, but they do have some overlap.

It seems magic and Whisper himself were a sticking point for a lot of people. I don’t get the witch stuff since I didn’t read it, but others had issues with it as well.

Kique definitely still hates writing women and is loathe to do F/F relationships. M/F ones only exist to pump out babies for his sequel. And if Kargo killing merchants were such a big deal, maybe that should have been established earlier in the comic. Right now, other dogs have done worse, like Ranach yet he’s got a forever bounty? Give me a break.

ashs death felt extremely unnecessary and just a, sad for shock factor.

the whole ending felt extremely rushed. and weirdly pressing that its happy when its not? like, whispers stuck forever in the forest. the cult is still out there and abusing its next set of victims. the holy father is prob praised as a fallen martyr against “demons” and the “temptress” little miss.
the possum just forced little miss into a witch role she never wanted. being more of a hindrance against little miss’s recovery.
the coyote brothers death was completely forgotten about. same with that stranger deer, whisper killed as well. no one gave out an alert for a black death deer after the party or what? i guess with him leashed to the forest others will be safe from his head explosions from here on.

whispers world views are also really wishy washy story wise. like, he follows the forests- everything returns to nature. then ignores that for his moms sake. then its dropped entirely from there to figure out what he is at the church- against his mom as well.
killed the coyote brother to end his suffering, but then gets angry over his grandmas death. overall his world views just became- what does the plot need right now.

I didn’t like IDK. If it was about a normal teen on the path of recovery I would have liked it but the magic was too much and Whisper’s characters was very lame. His plot about killing disabled animals didn’t even get resolved. It also feels very hypocritical since Little Miss leaves a cult to find herself becoming a witch and it’s painted on a good light even if she didn’t want to become one. The Christian cats are too black and white‚ one of the main characters’ death is very stupid and fast paced‚ etc. I don’t think it was a really good comic.

Now with Home‚ I don’t know what to say. It still makes no sense and the whole rebellion plot sucks big time. Interesting that Onofre’s mate was male‚ even background couples have to be m/m. Couldn’t Onofre be a female? I guess Kique still hates writing women.
Kargo being known for his dots is bullshit! We have seen more dogs with dots ffs and why do they care so much?? He killed two merchants yes but Ranach lived in a rape tribe for years and they don’t give a fuck now?